InsuliserBeta
Concepts · Heat

Why the U-value is not the whole story

The usual starting point is the U-value: the heat that leaks through each square metre of wall for every degree of difference between inside and outside. A lower U-value means less heat lost in winter, so lower heating bills. It is the right first number to look at, and it is what building regulations ask for.

But the U-value describes a wall on a day when nothing changes. Real homes live through daily swings: cool nights, sunny afternoons, walls that warm up and cool down. How a wall handles those swings affects how the home feels as well as what it costs.

  • Comfort: a wall that passes big swings through to the inside makes rooms overheat on sunny afternoons and cool quickly in the evening. A wall that damps and delays the swings keeps the inner surface and the room air steadier.
  • Running cost, if the heating follows the swings: a fast system on a room thermostat, such as a boiler with radiators, adds heat when the wall lets more out and cuts back when the sun warms it. Then the swings show up in the heating, which ramps up and down and needs enough capacity for the peaks. Two walls with the same net heat loss over a day can ask very different things of the system, and the one with bigger swings may use more energy.
  • Room temperature, if it can't: often the heating doesn't follow these swings at all. Many systems run to a schedule or a steady flow temperature, and some respond slowly. Wet underfloor heating takes hours to warm up or cool down. Heat pumps work best at a steady, modest output, and pushing them to chase swings means higher flow temperatures and lower efficiency. With systems like these, nothing corrects the swing, so the room temperature rises and falls with it. The cost then is mostly comfort, not the bill: rooms that overheat on sunny afternoons and cool in the evening.

So when you plan, look at the U-value for how much heat the wall keeps in, then at the decrement factor, decrement delay and inner face temperatures for how steady it keeps the room. Light, well-insulated walls can have an excellent U-value and a high decrement factor. Because their U-value is low, the swing that actually reaches the room is still small, but it arrives quickly. Adding thermal mass on the room side damps and delays it further. The simulator lets you test that for yourself. Each idea is explained in The U-value, Decrement factor and delay and Reading the results.